Digital Asset Management Software 2021
DAM Software
Digital Asset Management Software Reviews Completely Updated for 2021
The Digital Photography Workflow is composed of eight major steps. Read Life a Digital Image for the complete list and details. The optional sixth step is to index photographs so that they can easily be found in the future. Digital Asset Management (DAM) software are designed exactly to perform this task. They transcends media types which include images, videos, documents and other digital assets. For the scope of this article, we focus on software that have specific tools to manage images.
Originally, DAM Software strictly managed digital files and image processing was performed by dedicated programs such as Adobe Photoshop, the most famous imaging software. As image libraries grew, Adobe introduced a viewer called Adobe Bridge that incorporated some DAM features. The true revolution came when they introduced Adobe Lightroom, now officially called Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Classic. This software, referred simply as Lightroom from here on, combines digital asset management and basic image processing with non-destructive editing. Non-Destructive Editing existed in video applications for some time but this was the first imaging processing software to work this way.
Lightroom set the benchmark for photography workflow software which is why every DAM software reviewed here is compared against it. For years, Lightroom faced zero competition due to its affordability. Eventually, Adobe pulled Lightroom into its Creative Cloud subscription service, causing its cost to sky-rocket while tying users into a perpetual subscription. Crucially, its non-destructive nature implies that the final version of images only exist within Lightroom, making it highly improbable anyone would terminate their subscription.
Several Photography Workflow software recently launched while some DAM Software acquired image processing features and certain Image Processing software introduced DAM features. There are levels of DAM Software, ranging from free to expensive. Core features are common but each software provides its own distinct feature-set, reflecting its origin and evolution. This article reviews DAM software aimed at amateur and independent professional photographers.
Digital Asset Management Software contenders are:
- Adobe Lightroom Classic 10.1 - Windows & Mac OS
- Corel AfterShot Pro 3 (Formerly Bibble Pro) - Windows, Mac OS & Linux
- Phase One Capture One 20 - Windows & Mac OS
- IDimager Photo Supreme 5 - Windows & Mac OS
- Photools IMatch 2020 - Windows Only
- DxO PhotoLab 4 - Windows & Mac OS
- ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate 2021 - Windows Only
Among this list, IDImager and Photo Supreme are primarily DAM software with extensive support for cataloging images but limited processing capabilities. All others are full-fledged image possessing applications meant to cover a significant part of the digital photography workflow.
Software company Camera Bits makes a digital photography workflow software called Photo Mechanic Plus. After several attempts and reinstalling it twice on a new system image, it never managed to index any images. It worked as a standalone photo editor but that is out-of-scope for this review.
DAM Tasks
Digital Asset Management is essentially indexing of digital files with information to facilitate searching for assets that match certain criteria. Computers store files on a filesystem that gives each file a name, path and stores basic information about such as its size and last modification time. Within image files, there is more specific information called metadata. There are several types of metadata, including EXIF and IPTC. The former is initially embedded into images upon creation by the camera and possibly modified later. The latter is written by specialized software for the purpose of cataloging images. Finally there is XMP which is an XML file that stores metadata about an image.
All DAM Software read available metadata when they encounter images. This is frequently done during an Import step that gathers data prior to working with those images. Some software allow images to be opened without being imported first and progressively add their metadata. This limits there ability to index images which have not been opened yet, so most software have the explicit Import action.
Metadata built into images is fairly limited and so extra information is frequently added by users. The most generic such information are keywords. Keywords can be anything: Locations, People, Objects, Concepts, etc. Once images are associated with keywords, those can be later used to find matching images. Categorize are similar to keywords except that they can be organized into a a hierarchy. This means that one category belongs to another category, which may in turn belong to yet another.
Categories save work compared to keywords but one can be configured to emulate the other. A category which nor belongs to nor owns another is exactly like a keyword. Several keywords can be used to emulate categories. Instead of adding the Paris category which belongs to France which belongs to Europe, one would add all three as keywords. The result would make it possible to search using any location granularity.
The whole purpose of cataloging is to efficiently retrieve files at a later date without knowing where they are. This is where the efficiency, completeness and expressiveness of DAM Software really makes a difference. Queries should be easy to create and matching image are expected to appear quickly. Having ways to refine results and automatic frequent searches provide greater efficiency.
An important aspect of searching is that one must be able to search for images which are not present while the search is being performed. Due to storage limitations, images can be off-loaded onto optical media such as DVDs or even external hard disk drives. For this to work, DAM software store locally metadata and thumbnails of off-line images. This allows one to see which images match a search without having access to the actual file.
Selection of Keepers
Most DAM software provide flexible tools to compare images. This include side-by-side comparison with synchronous zooming which extremely useful when comparing frames captured in burst to determine which ones have critical focus and an ideal expression from the subject.
When using Digital Asset Management Software to download images it could be tempting to use the same software for selecting keepers. The issue causes a catch-22 situation since file organization is determined by the set of keepers and DAM software are dependent on file organization. There are two ways around this:
- Reorganize: Import into a triage folder, select the keepers from there and then use the software's folder reorganization features.
- Reimport: Import into an incubation catalog in which you select the keepers by tagging them with a special flag or metadata. Reimport the keepers into the final catalog when done. This may require an intermediate export step with some software.
Generally reorganization within DAM software is much slower than through the operating system because DAM software has to modify its associated data to keep track of location changes and properly find images later.
Please Support Neocamera
All information on Neocamera is provided free of charge yet running this website is a huge endeavor. Purchases made via affiliate links found throughout the site help keep it running and up-to-date. There is no additional cost to you, so please consider buying via these links to our affilates:
If you found any information on this site valuable and did not purchase via our affiliate links, please considering donating via PayPal:
Any amount will be greatly appreaciated. Thank you for your support!
File Organization
All Digital Asset Management Software manage digital assets but do not organize them. The distinction is that DAM software are there to catalog digital assets where they are stored. On the other hand, organizing assets is choosing where to store each asset, which is a user-driven task even though some software can copy or move digital assets into their intended location.
It is crucial to plan how files are organized across disks and within them. A folder hierarchy is the only organization visible to the operating system and to backup software. Moving files offline into optical disks or external drives is much easier with a good file organization. To allow backups and off-loading to optical disks, make sure top-level folders do not exceed the maximum size for your choice of optical media, for example 4.5GB to use DVDs and 24GB to use Blu-Ray.
With the huge size of videos, it is much less practical to use optical disks for off-site storage, so now larger top-level folders can be matched with available external disks drives. Even high resolution images today easily full-up a DVD but there is nothing that compared to the longevity and durability of optical media.
Benchmarking
Benchmarking interactive software is truly a complex endeavor. Speed is absolutely crucial to make software usable but with asynchronous processing, many tasks happen simultaneously. Users notice lag when they are waiting for something before they can take the next action, even though unfinished tasks could be progressing in the background.
Key tasks that determine the performance of DAM software are:
- Import: The time between selecting new images and them being available in the software.
- Image Preview: Showing a view of image-content of any quality.
- Image View: Viewing an image scaled to the application window.
- Full-Resolution Zoom: Viewing an image such that each pixel in the image is shown as one pixel on-screen.
- Image Switching: Switching the view between two images. This speed is crucial when comparing similar pictures.
- Tag Application: Time between tagging an image and being able to perform another action on the image.
- Image Search: Speed of searching for images by tag, metadata and attribute.
To provide even benchmarking of all the DAM Software reviewed here, Neocamera imported 25GB of identical images into each program using a clean HDD image restored to the exact same point on a state-of-the-art SATA III SSD with 520 MB/s read and 400 MB/s write speed. Although much faster NVMe are available, their price and size are prohibitive to use as primary photo storage.
Updates
2024.11.18
Best 2024 Photography Gifts for Every Budget
Great gifts for photographers and photo enthusiasts selected for every budget among the best products of 2024.
2024.08.07
Eye Protection Tips for Professional Photographers
The four main considerations for professional photographers regarding eyewear.
2024.07.14
Fujifilm X100VI Review
Flagship fixed-lens compact digital camera with a 40 MP sensor and Image-Stabilization, a first for the series. Retro design featuring dual control-dials, plus direct ISO, Shutter-Speed and EC dials. Its hybrid viewfinder can switch between EVF and OVF mode.
2024.05.09
Fujifilm GFX100 II Review
Flagship 102 Megapixels Medium-Format Mirrorless Digital Camera with 8-Stop 5-Axis IBIS, 8 FPS Drive, 8K Video and 400 MP Super-Resolution capture in a weatherproof and freezeproof body with dual control-dials and dual memory-card slots.
2024.04.03
Fujifilm X-T5 Review
Newest Fujifilm flagship boasting a 40 MP APS-C sensor, 5-axis IBIS with 7-stop efficiency, 15 FPS continuous drive, 6.2K Video capture, dual control-dials and dual SDXC UHS-II slots in a sturdy weatherproof and freezeproof body.
2023.11.20
Best Digital Cameras of 2023
Find out which are the Best Digital Cameras of 2023. All the new Mirrorless Digital Cameras from entry-level to high-end professional.
2023.07.10
Fujifilm X-H2 Review
40 Megapixels APS-C Hybrid Mirrorless Digital Camera with 7-stop IBIS. Fastest shutter ever and 8K video capture. Large builtin EVF with 0.8X magnification and 5.8 MP, plus an Eye-Start Sensor. Packed with features and large number of controls in a weatherproof and freezeproof body.
2023.05.07
Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G Review
Review of the unique Sony FE 20-70mm F/4G lens. The optical zoom of this lens spans ultra-wide-angle and medium focal-length coverage, making it one of the most versatile Full-Frame lenses on the market.
2023.01.15
Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 Review
Review of the Huion Inspiroy Dial 2 tablet, a medium sized drawing surface with dual dials and customizable buttons. Connects via USB-C or Bluetooth 5.0 with Windows, Linux and Android support.
2022.12.08
How to Pack for a Photo Trip
Find out how to pack for a travel photography trip, carry your gear safely while meeting airline regulations.
2022.11.13
Best Digital Cameras of 2022
The best digital cameras of 2022. A short list of the most outstanding models in their respective categories. Choose one for yourself or as a gift.
2022.09.21
Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM Review
Review of the Pentax DA* 60-250mm F/4 SDM, the constant-aperture telephoto zoom with the highest zoom-ratio on the market.
2024.11.18
2024.08.07
2024.07.14
2024.05.09
2024.04.03
2023.11.20
2023.07.10
2023.05.07
2023.01.15
2022.12.08
2022.11.13
2022.09.21
NEWS
2024.12.17
Venus Unveils 2 Tilt-Shift Macro Lenses
Lens
2024.12.17
Panasonic Lumix G97 and ZS99 Launched
Digital Camera
2024.11.19
Sony Unveils Their Brightest Zoom Lens
Lens
2024.11.19
Sony Finally Upgrades Alpha A1 Flagship Camera
Digital Camera
2024.11.12
New Laowa Slim Ultra-Wide Lens
Lens
2024.11.07
Hasselblad Adds XCD 75mm Lens
Lens
2024.11.07
Nikon Launches Z50 II
Digital Camera
2024.11.05
Venus Created Worlds First Shift Zoom Lens
Lens
2024.11.01
Nikon Announces Development of Standard Power-Zoom Lens
Lens
2024.10.30
Canon Launches 3D APS-C plus 3 Extra RF Lenses
Lens
2024.10.14
Fujifilm Extends APS-C Lineup
Digital Camera ○ Lens
2024.09.27
Leica Launches New Q3 with 43mm Lens
Digital Camera