Canon Powershot SX100 IS Review

The Canon Powershot SX100 IS packs an impressive feature set that includes a wide range of ISO, full-manual controls, manual focus, custom white-balance, exposure lock, choice of metering patterns and use of standard AA batteries. Among, compact ultra-zoom cameras, this is the only one with all these features. More features of this digital camera include a VGA movie mode, macro (1cm) & face-detect focus, built-in flash with red-eye reduction and slow-sync, single & continuous AF and multiple self-timers.

The Canon SX100 is the first compact ultra-zoom digital camera from Canon. With a 10X stabilized optical zoom lens in a body that is less than 2" thick, this digital camera has an appealing form-factor that is shared with very few other cameras.

With its standard 36-360mm zoom range and full manual-controls, the Canon Powershot SX100 is suitable for general photography with a preference for far away and macro subjects rather than large and close by ones like architecture and indoor scenery. Although both night and action photography are possible given the shutter-speed and ISO ranges available, performance will be the limiting factor at both extremes.

Ergonomically, the SX100 has a design which combines a smooth and comfortable hand-grip with enough space to rest the thumb against the camera's back. Buttons and dials are all easily accessible with little shift from the standard two-handed holding position. There are dedicated buttons for image playback and exposure compensation. While both these buttons are easy to activate, it would make much more sense if their positions were swapped so that exposure-compensation would be easier to reach while shooting.

The 4-way controller, which also rotates, gives direct access to ISO, focus, flash and drive modes. The rotating aspect is extremely useful while in manual or semi-automatic modes, plus it also allows faster menu navigation. The problem with this combined 4-way and rotating-wheel controller is that is very easy to accidentally activate the feature which you are not trying to use. During our review period, it frequently happened to activate one of the 4-way options while rotating the dial to change aperture or shutter-speeds.

The camera's 2.5" LCD features 172K pixels which make it quite sharp. Visibility is average in bright light with a good refresh rate. Under low light, the LCD gains up very well, although the refresh rate takes a dip. There are 4 buttons located below the LCD. This placement is very good because, when holding the camera with two hands, the left thumb can reach them quite comfortably. One of these buttons, labeled with the direct-print icon, is actually customizable, thus making it immensely more useful than its default purpose.

The Canon Powershot SX100 IS's sleek curves reveal a modern elegance and a feeling that there is something missing from this digital camera. Indeed, neither a viewfinder nor a flash disrupts the SX100's smooth design. A relatively weak flash is actually hidden behind the silver Canon logo. This does have two advantages. One, keeping the flash closed automatically ensures that it will never fire. Two, raising the flash gives it a greater distance from the lens which reduces the probability of red-eye and lens obstruction. As for a viewfinder, the Canon SX100 does not have one. This is clearly a compromise aimed at keeping this ultra-zoom compact and affordable: a EVF would add cost and bulk to the camera, while an optical tunnel would be impractical for such a zoom range.

The type of camera that combines a powerful zoom and a compact body must, apparently, compromise on image quality to a certain point. The image quality of the SX100 represents this compromise with both strong and weak points. Overall, image quality is reasonable but far from top-notch, specially compared to the Canon A-series of compact cameras which sport 3X to 6X zoom lenses.

Exposure is good and highly consistent. This digital camera produces bright results in most situations and requires less positive exposure compensation than most when faced with bright scenes. This is ideal for direct printing but occasionally clips highlights.

Colors from the Canon SX100 are generally accurate and well saturated without appearing over-saturated. White-balance is not perfect, but clearly better than average. Even automatic white-balance handled incandescent light sources better than most digital cameras. A slight bluish color-cast was noticed for snow-covered landscape under overcast sky.

Image noise is clearly this digital camera's weak point. At all ISO settings, even the lowest, noise is evident and definitely above average. This high noise causes a very noticeable loss of fine details in most images. ISO 80 to 200 are quite usable under most conditions but noise creeps up fast starting at ISO 400. By ISO 800, only the smallest print sizes can be recommended. The ISO 1600 setting produces useless results.

The big selling point of the Canon Powershot SX100 IS, its compact 10X zoom lens, is quite an achievement. Sharpness is solid with rather good edge-to-edge consistency. In our evaluation unit, there was softness only in the upper-left corner which may be a quality control problem since we have not seen this in images from other SX100 reviews.

Optical distortion are quite low for such a zoom range. At the normal focus range, a slight barrel distortion is visible at wide-angle. Similarly to most lens, this increases in macro mode. Chromatic aberrations are a bit higher than average but nothing terrible. The built in stabilization seems quite effective.

The SX100 holds its own well when it comes to speed. All controls are responsive, there is very little shutter-lag and shot-to-shot speed is quite good. Focusing is speedy in bright light and slower-but-decent in low light. The playback mode is extremely fast with nearly instant zooming and image browsing (except when using the rotating dial which purposefully slows down browsing to shot a useless animation). Startup and shutdown are average. The only slow aspects of the Canon SX100 are the continuous-drive and flash recycling time. This compact camera also performs very well in terms of battery-life using only 2 standard AA batteries.

Let's get the only serious problem out of the way: The Canon Powershot SX100 IS has a very noisy sensor that destroys details even at low ISO. No doubt about it, this bad for large prints and low-light shooting.

Nearly every other aspect of the SX100 in terms of quality, performance and feature set is impressive. Of the few compact ultra-zoom digital cameras around, this is the most feature rich. Having 10X optical zoom with built-in stabilization, full-manual controls, custom white-balance and the convenient use of AA batteries is presently unique.

Keeping this in mind, one must decide if this feature set is worth the high image noise. For the user who shares his images through the web and makes mostly small prints, the SX100 can be very appealing. Those who regularly make medium and large prints should settle for a larger camera.